Understanding Variable Annuities: Benefits, Drawbacks, and Insights
Variable annuities are one of the most complex and often misunderstood financial products available today. With their mix of market-based growth potential, insurance guarantees, and fees, they spark both interest and controversy. This page is designed to be an unbiased educational resource, helping you make sense of how variable annuities work, their benefits, drawbacks, and whether they align with your financial goals. Whether you’re a consumer or a financial professional, you’ll find clear, comprehensive insights to navigate this multifaceted product with confidence.
Variable Annuities | Table of Contents
What is a Variable Annuity (VA)
A Variable Annuity (VA) is a financial product that blends the growth potential of market investments with the security of insurance guarantees. Designed primarily for long-term retirement planning, VAs offer investors the ability to participate in the financial markets through customizable subaccounts while benefiting from features like tax-deferred growth and optional income or death benefit guarantees. This combination makes VAs unique, yet their complexity often leads to misunderstandings about their role in a financial portfolio.
Click Here and Return to The Main Annuity Page…
Definition and Purpose
Variable annuities were introduced in the mid-20th century as insurance companies sought to compete with mutual funds and other market-driven investment products which traditionally earned higher returns. At the time, traditional annuity products like Single Premium Immediate Annuities (SPIAs) and Fixed Deferred Annuities (FDAs) were losing ground as consumers gravitated toward those higher-risk/higher return potential opportunities. VAs emerged as a hybrid solution, offering market participation with the added security of insurance-backed guarantees making them both an investment and insurance product.
Market Exposure with Guarantees: Unlike traditional fixed annuities that focus solely on guaranteed returns, VAs allow contract owners to invest in market-linked subaccounts while providing a safety net through insurance protection and optional riders which add additional guarantees. This dual approach appeals to individuals who want the potential for higher returns without completely sacrificing financial security.
A Product for Changing Times: The introduction of VAs reflected shifting consumer preferences. With fewer employers offering defined benefit pensions, individuals increasingly relied on personal investments for retirement. VAs were positioned by agents as a way to bridge the gap by providing growth potential with an income component that mimics traditional pensions in one product.
Example:
A 50-year-old investor might choose a VA to invest in equity subaccounts during their working years while locking in guaranteed income for retirement through an optional rider if the value of the subaccounts falls do to an event like a stock market crash. This strategy offers both growth potential and peace of mind.
How Variable Annuities Are Different From Other Annuities and Investments
Variable annuities differ from other types of annuities, such as fixed and indexed annuities, in several significant ways:
Market Exposure
- Unlike fixed annuities, which offer guaranteed interest rates, VAs allow for investment in subaccounts tied to the performance of stocks, bonds, and other securities. This exposes the contract owner to market risks but also provides the opportunity for higher returns.
Customizable Investment Choices
- Another type of annuity, Indexed annuities, which sounds like an investment but is in fact a form of fixed annuity, links their returns to a specific market index (e.g., S&P 500) and often cap or restrict earnings potential do to internal costs. In contrast, VAs provide a broader range of investment options without the caps or restriction on earnings, allowing the owner earn unlimited returns when their underlying investments soar higher. However, the investment options available in any VA contract are still limited to only what the company has made available (Usually less than 50 choices.) In addition, many insurance companies require the contract to adhere to specific “allocation strategies” to manage risk and ensure they can provide the insurance benefits guaranteed by the contract.
Insurance Guarantees
- Unlike mutual funds, VAs offer guarantees backed by the issuing insurance company. These guarantees often include:
- Death Benefits: Ensuring beneficiaries receive at least the original premium amount (minus withdrawals) in the event of the owner’s death.
- Income Riders: Providing guaranteed lifetime income streams, even if the subaccount value drops to zero.
- Unlike mutual funds, VAs offer guarantees backed by the issuing insurance company. These guarantees often include:
Key Difference:
While other annuities focus on stability and safety, VAs cater to investors seeking growth while still offering a layer of protection against market volatility.
Key Features of Variable Annuities
Variable annuities are defined by their combination of tax advantages, investment options, and insurance benefits. Here’s an overview of their core features:
Tax-Deferred Growth
One of the most attractive features of VAs is the ability to grow investments tax-deferred.
How It Works:
Similar to IRAs and 401(k)s, VAs allow earnings to compound without being taxed until withdrawn. This deferral can significantly enhance long-term growth, especially for high-income earners who have already maxed out contributions to other tax-advantaged accounts.Why It Matters:
Tax-deferred growth enable investors to potentially save thousands of dollars over time because it delays taxation. This allows their money to compound more effectively.
Example:
A $200,000 VA invested in subaccounts earning an average of 7% annually grows to approximately $393,430 after 10 years. Without tax deferral, assuming a 25% tax rate, the balance would only grow to about $344,300—a difference of nearly $50,000.
On a negative note, when earnings from a VA are withdrawn by the original owner, they are taxed as ordinary income at the individual’s highest tax rate. This means the potential benefits of lower-taxed income—like long-term capital gains, qualified dividends, and the step-up in basis traditional investments receive at the owner’s death—are lost.
Subaccount Investment Options
Variable annuities offer subaccounts, which function like mutual funds, as their primary investment vehicle.
Range of Choices:
Subaccounts typically include a mix of equity, bond, and balanced funds. Some insurers also offer risk management tools like automatic rebalancing to help investors maintain a diversified portfolio.Why Limitations Exist:
While subaccounts offer variety, the choices are intentionally limited compared to traditional brokerage accounts. This restriction ensures that the insurer can manage its risk exposure and fulfill guarantees outlined in the contract.
Example:
A contract owner with a moderate risk tolerance might allocate 50% of their investment to equity subaccounts and 50% to bond subaccounts. This allocation allows for growth while reducing overall volatility.
Optional Riders
Variable annuities are known for their flexibility, thanks to optional riders that enhance benefits.
Enhanced Death Benefits:
- Basic Guarantee: Ensures beneficiaries receive the initial investment amount, even if the market underperforms.
- Step-Up Options: Periodically lock in the contract’s highest value, guaranteeing beneficiaries receive more than the initial premium.
Income Riders:
- Provide guaranteed income streams for life, even if the subaccount value is depleted.
- Include features like roll-up rates, which guarantee a set annual growth rate for the income base.
How Riders Add Value:
While these features increase costs, they offer critical peace of mind for investors who prioritize financial security.
Example:
A VA with a Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) may provide a 5% “roll-up minimum rate” on the income base, ensuring a higher payout for delayed withdrawals regardless of the contracts investment performance.
Variable annuities are a unique financial tool, offering a blend of investment flexibility, tax-deferred growth, and insurance-backed guarantees. Their purpose is to meet the needs of individuals seeking market exposure alongside the peace of mind provided by income and death benefit guarantees. By understanding their features, history, and differences from other annuities, investors can evaluate whether VAs align with their financial goals and risk tolerance.
How Variable Annuities Work
Variable annuities (VAs) are complex financial products that blend investment opportunities with insurance-backed guarantees. To understand their role in a financial plan, it’s essential to explore how they are funded, how their investments (subaccounts) operate, and the guarantees and riders that make them unique.
Funding a VA
Variable annuities are versatile in how they accept contributions, offering two primary methods of funding:
Single Premium Variable Annuity (SPVA):
This option involves a one-time lump-sum payment, making it ideal for individuals who have a significant amount of money to invest, such as proceeds from the sale of a business or inheritance. The funds are immediately allocated to chosen subaccounts, and the growth begins right away.Flexible Premium Variable Annuity (FPVA):
With this option, the owner can make multiple contributions over time, providing greater flexibility for those who want to invest incrementally. This structure is appealing for individuals building their retirement savings gradually. However, the insurance company may impose limits on how much and how often contributions can be made.
Considerations When Funding a VA:
- Qualified vs. Non-Qualified Funds:
While VAs are inherently tax-deferred, many are funded with qualified retirement money (like IRA or 401(k) rollovers). This means the tax-deferral benefit is redundant, but investors are often drawn to the guarantees and flexibility VAs offer. - Allocation Timing:
Contributions must be allocated to subaccounts or fixed accounts. How these funds are distributed will directly impact growth potential and risk exposure.
Subaccounts Explained
Subaccounts are the investment engine of variable annuities. They function similarly to mutual funds, offering a range of market-linked investment options that cater to varying levels of risk tolerance and financial goals.
What Are Subaccounts?
Subaccounts are pools of investments, such as stocks, bonds, and money market funds, available within the VA. Each subaccount represents a distinct investment strategy, allowing the owner to diversify their holdings.Limited Investment Choices:
While subaccounts offer diversification, they are more restricted than typical mutual funds or ETFs. Insurance companies limit the selection to ensure the sustainability of the guarantees provided within the annuity. For example:- Subaccounts often avoid highly speculative assets.
- Allocation caps may be imposed to prevent excessive risk.
Example:
A VA might offer 20-30 subaccount options, including large-cap equities, bond funds, and balanced portfolios. This ensures a variety of choices while protecting the insurer’s ability to meet contractual guarantees.
Why Limitations Exist:
Insurance companies must manage their own risk too! Guarantees, such as death benefits or lifetime income, depend on the insurer’s ability to cover liabilities even during market downturns. Therefore, they need to maintain some level of predictability. By limiting subaccount risk, they ensure the financial stability needed to honor these guarantees.Portfolio Management Features:
Many VAs include tools like automatic rebalancing and target-date fund options, helping investors maintain a consistent risk profile over time too.
Insurance Guarantees and Riders
One of the defining features of variable annuities is the insurance guarantees and optional riders that provide financial security, even in volatile markets. These features are supported by fees, primarily the Mortality and Expense (M&E) charges, which cover the insurer’s risk.
Breakdown of M&E Charges
What Are M&E Charges?
Mortality and Expense charges are fees that compensate the insurer for the guarantees embedded in the VA. These charges typically range from 1.0% to 1.5% annually and are deducted from the contract value.Purpose of M&E Charges:
- To fund the base death benefit, which ensures that beneficiaries receive at least the total premium paid (minus withdrawals) if the market value drops.
- To offset administrative costs and the financial risk assumed by the insurer.
Example:
If a VA owner invests $200,000 and the market value drops to $150,000, the insurer guarantees that the beneficiary will receive no less than $200,000 upon the owner’s death if the account balance stays below the initial premium.
Enhanced Death Benefit Options
Standard death benefits can be upgraded with enhanced riders for additional fees. These options are particularly attractive for those focused on legacy planning.
Step-Up Death Benefits:
- Periodically “lock in” the contract’s highest value (e.g., annually).
- If the market declines, the death benefit reflects the locked-in value rather than the current market value.
Return of Premium Benefits:
- Guarantees that beneficiaries receive at least the total premiums paid, even after partial withdrawals.
Example:
John invests $300,000 in a VA with a step-up rider. Over 10 years, the contract’s highest value reaches $450,000. Even if the market value drops to $350,000 at the time of his death, his beneficiaries will receive $450,000. Unlike life insurance which has an “income tax free death benefit”, the death benefit of annuity that exceeds the contracts tax basis ($300,000 in this example) is eventually taxed as ordinary income.
Lifetime Income and Withdrawal Riders
Income riders are among the most sought-after features of variable annuities, as they allow the contract owner to take risk while ensuring they can receive a steady income stream regardless of market performance. As long as income limits are followed, VA contracts with income and withdrawal riders will continue to pay even if the sub-account values are at $0.
Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefits (GLWB):
- Allows the owner to withdraw a set percentage of the income base (often 4%-6%) for life, even if the contract value is depleted.
- Includes roll-up rates, where the income base grows by a guaranteed minimum percentage annually (e.g., 5%-7%) if withdrawals are deferred.
Other Income Riders:
- Guaranteed Minimum Income Benefits (GMIB): Ensures a minimum lifetime income, regardless of subaccount performance, so that income will continue even if the contracts value is depleted.
- Guaranteed Minimum Accumulation Benefits (GMAB): Guarantees the contract value will not fall below a specified level after a set period.
Example:
Sarah invests $250,000 in a VA with a GLWB. She defers withdrawals for 10 years, during which her income base grows to $400,000 due to a 5% annual roll-up. At retirement, she begins withdrawing $20,000 annually (5% of $400,000) for life, even if the subaccount value declines to zero.
Variable annuities combine market-based growth potential with insurance guarantees, making them a unique financial tool for long-term planning. Understanding how they work—from funding options to subaccount operations and the role of riders—is essential for evaluating their suitability. While the benefits are attractive, such as tax deferral and lifetime income guarantees, the associated costs and complexities must be carefully weighed. A thorough understanding of these features ensures that investors can make informed decisions about how VAs fit into their broader financial goals.
Benefits of Variable Annuities
Variable annuities (VAs) are designed to offer a unique mix of investment opportunities and insurance guarantees, catering to individuals looking to grow their wealth and/or generate income from their assets, while managing various financial risks. But how do these benefits work in real life? Let’s explore the key advantages of VAs to help you decide if they fit into your financial strategy.
Tax-Deferred Growth
One of the most notable advantages of VAs is their ability to grow investments without immediate taxation. Unlike taxable accounts where earnings are reduced by annual taxes, VAs allow your money to compound tax-deferred over time. This can be a significant advantage for investors focused on long-term growth.
For instance, let’s assume you invest $100,000 in a VA earning 5% annually, it would grow to approximately $265,000 over 20 years. In contrast, a taxable account might only reach $223,000 after factoring in taxes on gains each year. This difference, fueled by tax deferral, can be perceived as a positive aspect for building retirement savings, but be aware, taxes will be due when the earnings are removed from the contract. Therefore, the net affect may be more or less depending on the contract owners tax bracket when the taxes were deferred and when the earnings are taken out.
Tax deferral can be especially valuable for individuals in high tax brackets who have already maxed out their IRAs or 401(k)s and anticipate they will be in a lower tax bracket when it comes time to take income. VAs provide another option to shelter investments from current taxes while giving you access to a range of market-driven subaccounts.
While the tax-deferral feature is appealing, it’s important to consider the fees too. Charges like Mortality and Expense (M&E) fees and optional rider costs can chip away at your returns, reducing the overall benefit of tax deferral. Understanding the impact of these costs is essential before committing to a VA.
Investment Options with Risk Management
Variable annuities stand out because they are the only financial product that offer access to investment subaccounts that provide equity market exposure with insurance protection. These subaccounts function like mutual funds, allowing you to diversify your investments across stocks, bonds, and other assets. But what makes this feature particularly appealing is the layer of protection provided by the insurance company to provide death benefit and/or income benefits.
For investors hesitant to dive into the stock market due to fear of losses, VAs offer a reassuring safety net. The base death benefit ensures that even if markets falter, your beneficiaries will receive at least the amount you originally invested (minus withdrawals). This peace of mind often encourages individuals to take market risks they might otherwise avoid which, if successful, can help their money’s purchasing power keep up and possibly outpace inflation.
Additionally, VAs provide tools like automatic rebalancing, helping you maintain your preferred investment mix without constant oversight. This combination of flexibility and perceived security can be empowering for investors who want to participate in the market but need the comfort of guarantees.
While subaccounts provide diversification, they often come with limitations. Insurers restrict investment options to manage their own risk, and high fees can make it challenging for your portfolio to recover from market downturns. Over time, these costs may hinder the growth potential you hoped to achieve.
Guarantees and Optional Riders
One of the defining features of VAs is the range of optional riders available, which can be customized to meet specific financial goals. These riders provide additional guarantees that set VAs apart from traditional investment accounts.
Enhanced Death Benefits:
Step-up and return-of-premium options offer security for legacy planning. For example, a step-up benefit might lock in the highest value your contract reaches during its term, ensuring that your beneficiaries receive more than the market value if you pass away. While these features can provide peace of mind, it’s important to remember that they come with additional costs, which can erode the long-term value of your investment.Lifetime Income Riders:
Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefits (GLWBs) and similar riders ensure that you receive a predictable income stream, regardless of market performance. These features are particularly appealing to retirees seeking stability. However, it’s worth noting that the income provided by VAs is often lower than that of simpler fixed products like Single Premium Immediate Annuities (SPIAs).
These guarantees can be valuable, but they come at a cost. It’s essential to evaluate whether the benefits outweigh the fees based on your individual financial situation.
Psychological Benefits of Variable Annuities
Beyond the numbers, VAs offer psychological benefits that resonate with many investors. For some, the peace of mind that comes with insurance guarantees is just as important as the financial returns.
Easing Risk Aversion:
Many people hesitate to invest in the stock market because they fear losing their hard-earned money. VAs help alleviate this anxiety by offering guarantees like death benefits and income riders. Knowing that there’s a safety net in place often gives investors the confidence to take calculated risks they might otherwise avoid.Behavioral Simplicity:
VAs allow for a “set-it-and-forget-it” approach to investing. With features like automatic rebalancing and built-in guarantees, you can feel secure about your retirement planning without constantly monitoring your investments. This simplicity can be a huge relief for individuals who prefer a hands-off strategy.
Keep in Mind: While the psychological benefits are real, they can sometimes lead to misplaced confidence. The high fees associated with VAs can prevent portfolios from recovering after market losses, creating a gap between expectations and reality. It’s essential to balance these perceived benefits with the potential drawbacks.
Flexible Financial Planning Tool
Variable annuities are often marketed as a versatile solution that can address multiple financial needs, from income generation to legacy planning.
Legacy Planning:
Death benefits provide reassurance that your beneficiaries will receive at least part of your investment, even in volatile markets. Enhanced options like step-ups can further increase this security. However, it’s important to be realistic about the net value your beneficiaries will receive after accounting for fees and market performance.Customized Solutions:
With optional riders, VAs can be tailored to fit your specific goals, whether you’re focused on lifetime income, market growth, or protecting your principal. This flexibility is one of the key reasons investors consider VAs.
A Thought to Consider: While VAs offer customization, the costs of these features can add up quickly. For many investors, simpler, lower-cost solutions may achieve the same goals more efficiently.
Who Can Benefit From Buying Variable Annuities?
Variable annuities (VAs) are not a one-size-fits-all solution, but they can serve specific financial needs for certain individuals. Most VA purchases today are made with retirement account rollovers, such as funds from 401(k)s or IRAs. In these cases, the contracts are not used for their tax-deferral advantages—since retirement accounts already offer that feature—but instead for the unique guarantees they provide.
Common Scenarios Where VAs May Fit:
Retirees Seeking Guaranteed Income Benefits:
Many retirees use VAs to secure lifetime income streams, especially through riders like Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefits (GLWBs). These riders offer peace of mind, ensuring a predictable income even if the underlying investments perform poorly. While the income is typically lower than that provided by SPIAs, the potential for account appreciation adds an element of growth that appeals to some investors.Legacy Planning with Death Benefits:
The base death benefit ensures that beneficiaries will receive at least the original investment, minus any withdrawals, even if market losses occur. Enhanced death benefit options, like step-ups, lock in account highs at regular intervals, offering added security. This is particularly appealing for individuals who want to leave a financial legacy while maintaining market exposure during their lifetime.Risk-Averse Investors with Growth Ambitions:
VAs can help risk-averse individuals participate in the stock market without the fear of losing everything. The combination of subaccount flexibility and insurance guarantees creates a perceived safety net, making it easier to take on market risk.
Understanding the Real Drivers of VA Purchases:
It’s worth noting that tax deferral, often touted as a key benefit of VAs, is not the primary reason they are purchased. In most cases, the funds used to buy VAs already come from tax-advantaged retirement accounts, meaning the tax-deferral feature is redundant. Instead, buyers are typically drawn to the guarantees VAs provide, such as:
- Lifetime income riders to address longevity risk.
- Death benefits that protect beneficiaries from market losses.
- The potential for account growth alongside these guarantees.
However, these benefits come at a cost. High fees, such as Mortality and Expense (M&E) charges and rider costs, can erode the value of the contract over time, making it critical to evaluate whether the guarantees justify the expense.
When to Consider Alternatives:
For some investors, other products may provide comparable guarantees or growth potential with fewer drawbacks:
- SPIAs: Offer higher guaranteed lifetime income without the complexity or fees tied to subaccounts and market fluctuations.
- Fixed Deferred Annuities: Provide principal protection and predictable growth, ideal for conservative savers who value stability.
- Equity Indexed Annuities (EIAs): Combine principal protection with growth tied to a market index, offering a middle ground between traditional fixed annuities and variable annuities, though they typically have limited upside due to caps or participation rates.
- Structured Products: Non-insurance financial instruments designed to offer some level of downside protection while participating in market gains. These products lack the insurance company-backed guarantees of annuities but do use derivative contracts to hedge risk. As such, they may appeal more to those seeking a mix of safety and growth without the complexity or high costs of VAs.
Each alternative has its unique advantages and trade-offs, and understanding these options can help you align your financial strategy with your specific goals and risk tolerance.
Variable annuities can provide meaningful benefits in certain scenarios, particularly for those seeking guaranteed income or legacy protection. However, the value of these benefits must be weighed against their high costs and the complexity of the contracts. By understanding why VAs are purchased—primarily for their guarantees rather than tax-deferral features—you can better assess whether they align with your financial goals or whether simpler, more cost-effective alternatives might serve you better.
Drawbacks of Variable Annuities
Variable annuities (VAs) come with notable advantages, but they also have drawbacks that are critical to understand. The costs, complexity, and potential tax inefficiencies can significantly impact their value. Let’s explore these challenges to help you make an informed decision.
Fees and Expenses
Variable annuities often carry some of the highest fees in the financial product landscape. These fees can erode the growth potential of the investment, making it difficult for the account to achieve meaningful returns. When the long-term anticipated growth before fees is 8%, and the total fee in a contract is 3% or higher, a majority of the earnings are consumed by fees leaving little left for the contract’s owner. Some of these fees include:
Commissions and Surrender Charges:
Insurance agents earn commissions from selling VAs, which are “baked” into the product’s structure. Commissions on VA products are as much as 7% of the initial premium. To recoup these costs, insurance companies impose surrender charges, which are penalties for withdrawing money during a specific period (typically 5-10 years). This limits your liquidity and can make early withdrawals costly.Ongoing Fees:
VAs include Mortality and Expense (M&E) charges, administrative fees, and rider costs for optional benefits like guaranteed income or enhanced death benefits. There is also the fees each separate account charges for managing the funds. For instance, a typical VA may have fees totaling 2-4% annually, which as stated before, can severely impact your returns. The fees unique to the VA contract are often charged against “high-water marks”, meaning the percentage being charged in relation to the actual account value is much higher. These fees seriously impact the performance of the contract, especially during market downturns.Free-Look Period – Use it to review your contract:
Most states mandate a “free-look” period, typically 10-30 days, during which time you can review your contract and cancel it without penalty. This is a crucial opportunity to scrutinize the fees and assess whether the product aligns with your financial goals.
Limited Investment Choices
Unlike brokerage accounts, which offer broad access to stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, VAs restrict your investment options to a predefined set of subaccounts. These subaccounts are carefully curated by the insurance company to manage their financial risk and ensure they can meet their contractual guarantees.
Why the Limitations Exist:
Insurers design subaccounts to stay within a specific risk profile, balancing potential returns with the guarantees they offer on death benefits and income riders. This often means you won’t have access to specialized or niche investments, which could limit your diversification strategies.Impact on Growth:
While subaccounts provide market exposure, the limited selection may prevent you from fully optimizing your portfolio, especially if you want to pursue advanced strategies or invest in alternative asset classes.
Complexity and Misunderstanding
Variable annuities are inherently complex products, with detailed contracts outlining how benefits, fees, and investment options function. Unfortunately, this complexity often leads to misunderstandings.
Understanding the Contract:
It’s critical to read and understand the terms of the VA contract, as the insurance company’s obligations are based strictly on the written agreement. Verbal assurances or simplified explanations from an agent may not fully capture the nuances of the product.Misaligned Expectations:
Many investors believe VAs provide more flexibility or higher returns than they actually do. For example, guarantees like death benefits or income riders are often misunderstood as free perks when they are, in fact, costly add-ons. Clear communication and careful review are essential to avoid surprises later.
Tax Inefficiency
While tax deferral is a key selling point for VAs, the taxation of earnings upon withdrawal can be less favorable than other investment vehicles.
100% Taxed as Ordinary Income:
For non-retirement accounts (after-tax money), all earnings withdrawn from a VA are taxed as ordinary income, which is typically at a higher rate than long-term capital gains or qualified dividends. This eliminates the potential tax advantages of other investments, such as stocks held in taxable accounts.No Step-Up in Basis:
When a VA owner passes away, the beneficiary does not receive a step-up in basis on the contract’s earnings. Instead, the earnings are taxed as ordinary income when the beneficiary withdraws the funds. This contrasts with stocks or mutual funds, where the basis is adjusted to the asset’s value at the time of the owner’s death, often eliminating capital gains taxes entirely.Missed Tax Efficiency:
Investors who use non-retirement money to purchase VAs may lose the opportunity to leverage tax-efficient investment strategies, such as municipal bonds, dividend-paying stocks, or index funds, which can offer lower tax liabilities.
While variable annuities provide valuable features like guaranteed income and market participation, their drawbacks—high fees, limited investment choices, complexity, and tax inefficiencies—can significantly impact their overall value. It’s essential to weigh these challenges against your financial goals and explore alternative solutions that may offer similar benefits with fewer trade-offs. Taking the time to understand these factors will empower you to make a more informed decision about whether a VA is the right choice for you.
Taxation on Variable Annuities
Understanding the tax implications of variable annuities (VAs) is essential for making informed financial decisions. From contributions to withdrawals, how you structure your contract and use it within your broader financial plan can significantly affect your tax liabilities.
Contributions to Variable Annuities
When purchasing a VA, you can choose between two primary account types: non-qualified (NQ) accounts or qualified retirement accounts like IRAs. Here’s how contributions work for each:
Non-Qualified Contracts:
- No Contribution Limits: Unlike retirement accounts, non-qualified VAs have no annual contribution limits, making them an appealing option for high-income earners looking to invest large sums.
- No Immediate Tax Benefits: Contributions are made with after-tax dollars and do not qualify for tax deductions. However, earnings grow tax-deferred, and taxes are only due when withdrawals are made.
- Potential for Deducting Losses: If the total contract value falls below the original contributions, you may be able to deduct the loss on your taxes, but only if the contract is fully surrendered.
Traditional IRAs:
- Tax-Deductible Contributions: Contributions to a VA within a Traditional IRA may qualify for a tax deduction, depending on your income and whether you’re covered by a workplace retirement plan.
- Tax-Deferred Growth: Earnings grow tax-deferred, but all withdrawals, including the original contributions, are taxed as ordinary income.
- Contribution Limits: Annual contributions are capped at $6,500 (or $7,500 for individuals aged 50 and older) in 2024.
Roth IRAs:
- After-Tax Contributions: Contributions to a VA within a Roth IRA are made with after-tax dollars and do not qualify for deductions.
- Tax-Free Growth and Withdrawals: Earnings grow tax-free, and withdrawals are tax-free if the account has been open for at least five years and you are over 59½.
- Income Limits: Eligibility to contribute to a Roth IRA phases out for high-income earners, starting at $138,000 (single) or $218,000 (married filing jointly) in 2024.
Withdrawal and Income Taxation
Withdrawals from a VA are taxed differently depending on whether the contract is qualified or non-qualified:
Non-Qualified Contracts:
- Earnings First (LIFO): Withdrawals follow the “last in, first out” (LIFO) rule, meaning earnings are withdrawn first and taxed as ordinary income. Only after all earnings are withdrawn does the principal become accessible tax-free.
- Annuitized Payments: When a non-qualified contract is annuitized, the exclusion ratio applies, allowing a portion of each payment to be tax-free as a return of principal.
- Distributions taken out before 59.5 years old may be subject to a 10% penalty in addition to any taxes owed.
Traditional IRAs:
- All withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income, regardless of whether the funds represent original contributions or earnings. This includes amounts withdrawn from the VA.
- As with any retirement account, distributions taken before age 59.5 may be subject to an additional 10% penalty.
Roth IRAs:
- Withdrawals are tax-free as long as you meet the requirements for qualified distributions (age 59½ and account open for at least five years).
- As with other ROTH IRA’s, withdrawals from a ROTH IRA annuity is performed on a First In-First Out basis. Therefore, ROTH IRA annuity owners can withdraw funds income tax and tax penalty free at anytime for any reason up to the basis of the contract.
Roth Conversion with Variable Annuities
For qualified VAs with income riders, there’s a unique opportunity to reduce taxes while maximizing tax-free income through a Roth conversion strategy.
The Strategy:
If your VA’s account value diminishes due to market losses but you retain a guaranteed income rider, you can convert the remaining balance to a Roth IRA.- Example:
Suppose you initially invest $1,000,000 in a VA with a guaranteed income rider paying 5% annually ($50,000). After years of withdrawals and poor market performance, the account value is reduced to say ~$6,000. By converting the remaining $6,000 to a Roth IRA and paying taxes on only this small amount, the $50,000 annual income benefit (based on the initial premium) becomes entirely tax-free for the rest of your life.
- Example:
Why It Works:
The guaranteed income is based on the high-water mark of the contract, not its current value. Once converted to a Roth IRA, the income is no longer subject to ordinary income taxes, providing significant long-term tax savings.Key Considerations:
- This strategy is most effective when the account value is near depletion, as the lower conversion amount minimizes upfront tax liability.
- Consult with a tax professional or financial advisor to ensure compliance with IRS rules and to evaluate the overall benefits.
1035 Exchange: Tax-Free Transfers Between Insurance Contracts
A 1035 exchange refers to a provision in the Internal Revenue Code (Section 1035) that allows individuals to exchange one insurance or annuity contract for another without triggering immediate tax liabilities. This rule is particularly beneficial for those looking to upgrade their financial strategy or switch to a contract better aligned with their current needs.
How Does a 1035 Exchange Work?
When you perform a 1035 exchange, the funds from your existing life insurance or annuity contract are transferred directly to a new annuity or life insurance contract. This transfer allows you to defer taxes on any gains accumulated in the original contract. Importantly, this exchange must be done directly between the insurance companies to qualify for tax-free treatment.
Tax-Deferred Growth Continues: By using a 1035 exchange, the value transferred maintains its tax-deferred status, avoiding any taxes on growth or earnings at the time of the transfer.
- Cost Basis Transfers: The original cost basis (the amount you’ve already paid in after-tax dollars) of the old contract carries over to the new one. This is particularly important if the old contract has significant gains, as the basis determines how much of future withdrawals are taxable.
1035 Exchanges and Life Insurance
One lesser-known benefit of 1035 exchanges is that they can also be used to transfer funds from a life insurance policy into an annuity contract.
- Life Insurance to Annuity: If you have a life insurance policy that you no longer need for its death benefit, you can transfer its cash value into an annuity to avoid paying current taxes on any gains or recapture any losses the life policy has experienced due to investment losses or fees (including costs for insurance.) This allows you to convert the accumulated cash value into a tax-deferred retirement income stream or use losses to offset future earnings in the new annuity contract.
- Cost Basis Carries Over: When exchanging a life insurance policy for an annuity, the cost basis from the life insurance transfers to the annuity. This means that the portion of the annuity withdrawals considered as a return of principal (basis) will remain tax-free.
Key Rules and Considerations
To ensure a smooth 1035 exchange, it’s essential to follow the IRS guidelines closely:
Like-for-Like Transfers: The exchange must involve “like-kind” properties. For example:
- An annuity can only be exchanged for another annuity.
- A life insurance policy can be exchanged for another life insurance policy or an annuity.
Direct Transfer Required: The funds must move directly between the insurance companies. If the policyholder takes possession of the funds, it may trigger a taxable event.
Why Consider a 1035 Exchange?
A 1035 exchange can be a powerful tool for improving your financial strategy without tax consequences. Common reasons to consider one include:
- Upgrading to a different contract with better terms, features, or lower fees.
- Consolidating multiple annuities into one for simplified management.
- Transitioning from a life insurance policy you no longer need to an annuity and to delay taxation on the life insurance policy’s gain/recapture any reduction in the life policy basis from fees, losses, or insurance costs.
The 1035 exchange provides flexibility for managing your financial assets while preserving tax advantages. Whether you’re upgrading to a more suitable annuity, consolidating contracts, or repurposing a life insurance policy, this provision ensures that your hard-earned savings continue to grow tax-deferred. However, it’s important to weigh the costs, features, and potential surrender charges of the new contract carefully. Consult a financial advisor to determine if a 1035 exchange aligns with your goals and needs.
The tax implications of variable annuities are multifaceted and depend heavily on how the contract is structured and used. Non-qualified contracts offer tax-deferral but lack the upfront benefits of retirement accounts, while Roth IRAs provide an avenue for tax-free growth and withdrawals. Understanding the nuances of contributions, withdrawals, and advanced strategies like Roth conversions can help you optimize your VA’s value and reduce your overall tax burden. By carefully considering these factors, you can align your annuity with your broader financial goals.
Key Considerations Before Buying a Variable Annuity
Purchasing a variable annuity (VA) is a significant financial decision that requires careful thought and understanding. These contracts offer unique benefits, but their complexities mean they aren’t suitable for everyone. Before committing, it’s essential to evaluate the contract thoroughly, understand the associated costs, and determine how it fits into your broader financial goals.
Importance of the Free-Look Period
Being complex financial contracts, agents may sometime over simplify the contract to get a sale which can lead to higher expectations that what the contract can provide. The free-look period is a crucial consumer protection feature that gives you time to review your variable annuity contract after purchase so you can “read the fine print” and understand exactly what the guarantees entail. Depending on state regulations, this period typically lasts between 10 and 30 days.
What It Is:
During the free-look period, you can cancel the contract for any reason without incurring penalties or surrender charges. If you decide the VA doesn’t align with your needs or expectations, you’ll typically receive a full refund of your premium payments.Why It Matters:
VAs are complex products with intricate terms and conditions. The free-look period allows you to:- Evaluate the fees, riders, and guarantees outlined in the contract.
- Ensure the investment aligns with your financial goals and risk tolerance.
- Seek a second opinion from a financial advisor or attorney if needed.
This period provides a safety net for consumers, ensuring you’re not locked into a product that doesn’t meet your needs.
Questions to Ask
Before purchasing a variable annuity, it’s essential to ask the right questions to fully understand the product and its implications. These questions can help you make an informed decision and avoid unpleasant surprises down the line.
“What are the total fees, including riders and subaccount management?”
- Understand the full cost of the VA, including M&E charges, rider fees, and subaccount management fees.
- Ask how these fees will impact your account’s growth potential, especially in volatile markets.
“What are the terms of the guarantees and benefits?”
- If the VA includes income or death benefit guarantees, review the terms carefully.
- Clarify how these guarantees are calculated, particularly for riders based on high-water marks.
“How does this fit into my overall financial plan?”
- Determine whether the VA aligns with your retirement, legacy, or income planning goals.
- Consider how the annuity complements other investments or insurance products in your portfolio.
A variable annuity can be a valuable financial tool, but its complexity and costs make it essential to conduct due diligence before committing. Take advantage of the free-look period to ensure the contract aligns with your expectations and ask detailed questions to fully understand the product’s terms and fees. By approaching your decision with careful consideration, you can determine whether a VA is the right fit for your financial strategy.
At Decision Tree Financial, we do not sell Variable Annuity Contracts. We do though understand how they work. If you need help understanding if a Variable Annuity Contract is right for you or reviewing the contract during your free look period, CONTACT US and we will make sure you understand your choices so you make the best decision for your unique situation.
Learn More About Specific Annuity Types Below
A Single Premium Immediate Annuity (SPIA) converts a lump sum payment into a guaranteed income stream that begins almost immediately, typically within 30 days. SPIAs are ideal for retirees seeking predictable cash flow for a set period or for life. The insurer assumes the investment risk, ensuring stability and peace of mind for the annuitant.
A Fixed Deferred Annuity (FDA) allows you to invest a lump sum or series of payments, earning a guaranteed interest rate over time. These funds can grow tax-deferred and later be withdrawn, provide a death benefit to beneficiaries, or be annuitized to generate income at a future date, offering flexibility and stability for long-term financial goals.
A Variable Annuity (VA) allows you to invest your premiums in a selection of subaccounts, similar to mutual funds, offering the potential for higher returns based on market performance. While investment risk is borne by the contract owner, optional riders like guaranteed income or death benefits provide added security. Funds can grow tax-deferred and be withdrawn, be used to provide a death benefit or provide and income stream at a later date.
An Equity Indexed Annuity (EIA) combines the safety of a fixed annuity with growth potential tied to a stock market index, such as the S&P 500. Your principal is protected from market downturns, while returns are based on index performance, subject to caps or participation rates. Funds can grow tax-deferred, provide a death benefit, or be annuitized for future income.
Longevity annuities are unique deferred contracts designed to provide significant income later in life, often starting at age 80 or 85. Unlike traditional deferred annuities, these contracts leverage mortality tables instead of generating returns. Funds generated from those who don’t reach the payout phase increase payment amounts for those who do.
Period Certain Income Annuities provide guaranteed income for a fixed period, such as 10, 20 or 30 years, regardless of whether the annuitant lives or passes away during period. Payments continue to beneficiaries if the owner dies before the period ends. These annuities offer predictable cash flow and income planning opportunities but do not extend past the period.